Happy Ending Madoka

I really liked this! You definitely put in a lot of work into clipping the video together. I've seen Madoka Magica before and I wasn't exactly sure how you were going to pull off the happy ending...but then I saw the Puella Magi Holy Quintet and I was pleasantly surprised (never saw that before). I think you accomplished your goal of making a happy ending, although I suppose new views could still be a bit confused about the whole concept of these magic girls (which can get confusing). I agree that consistent subtitles would have been really nice and its awesome that you even included an ending song (y). I think your project would have benefited from more explanation in the beginning as well, but I think that within this limited amount of time that you did very well.

This was pretty great. I haven't seen the anime, and was EXTREMELY confused, but I'll take your word for a lot of this making sense. Even the parts I didn't understand, it seemed like everyone was on top of their game and they more or less had the situation under control. I really liked your use of the in-anime transitions, but found that having them too close together broke the illusion that this was the whole story.
Consistent subtitles or more explanation of what was going on would've certainly helped me understand the project more.

Overall, great job, and I wish I knew more about the anime to full appreciate the project.