Structure, shape

I wanted to use the black shapes to capture the strong shadows in the original image, and I like the effect that gave me. Like the translation with lines and dots, this corresponds closely to the photograph it was adapted from, and both are fairly simple compositions. Unfortunately making the shadow into a shape takes it from being a kind of negative space to seeming like the focus of this picture. The huge black blob really dominates the image, taking away from the strong presence the columns had in the other two, so I don't think this was probably the most effective translation of the photo.